Ten teachers, one guitar video, ten different marks. Most of the gap comes from arguments about lighting, sound and editing. A rubric is worth having only if it makes markers listen for timing, pitch and hand control, the things a camera tends to hide.
Grade the playing, not the camera
A polished video can hide exactly what you need to see. Compression softens string noise. A camera angle hides a tense fretting wrist. An edit removes the moment the pulse slipped. So decide what the video has to show before you set up the grade in Moodle.
The question is simple: can a marker judge timing, pitch, articulation, hand position and whether the piece holds together? One student knows every note but rushes the chord changes. Another keeps perfect time but lets strings ring when they should stop. A single "performance quality" score turns both cases into an argument about taste.
This rubric is for one student's recording. Ear-training quizzes, course completion and a full guitar curriculum need their own tools. The rubric makes one performance easy to judge, scores it against clear descriptions and gives feedback for the next take.
Decide how the video must be recorded
Choose the recording rule first. A single uninterrupted take shows how a student recovers from mistakes, keeps time, mutes and prepares. It suits chord changes, scales, riffs, playing along to a click and short solo pieces. Ask students to say their name or ID on camera only if your privacy policy allows it. A comment with the submission can confirm who recorded it without putting personal details in the video.
Edited videos make sense in recording or arranging classes, where editing is part of the skill. But they tell you little about whether the picking hand keeps up or whether a student can hold tempo through a hard bar. Do not mix the two. If you allow edits, ask for a list of them and judge whether the finished performance hangs together. For technique, ask for one continuous take.
Both hands must be visible in the passages you mark. The guitar must be loud enough to hear how notes start and stop, which strings are muted and whether notes are in tune. A phone on a stand, angled slightly towards the picking hand, is usually enough. If you demand a studio microphone, a particular guitar or a face-on shot, you end up testing the student's budget and appearance instead of their playing.
Agree how you will handle students who need adjustments before the deadline. Judge how efficiently and comfortably they move and whether their hand use suits the task, not their body shape, disability or style. A student with an adapted setup may need a different camera angle or a changed technical expectation. Write the adjustment in your grading notes so every marker applies it the same way.
Clear descriptions stop taste replacing feedback
Good rubrics describe what you can see and hear. "Good timing" means whatever each marker privately thinks it means. "Keeps the stated pulse through the chord change and lets notes go on purpose" points to something in the clip. This matters most when two teachers are a whole level apart on the same video.
For a balanced check, give timing, pitch, articulation, posture and technique, and continuity 20 points each. The maths is easy to follow, and camera quality cannot outweigh groove. A specialist unit can change the weights for a clear musical reason: a bending study might count pitch for more, funk rhythm playing might count timing and articulation for more. Never change the rubric after students have submitted.
Four levels are easier to defend than lots of small steps: secure, mostly secure, inconsistent, and not enough evidence. The two middle levels should describe a musical problem that keeps happening. Words like "adequate" and "needs work" describe nothing.
Back the descriptions with numbers
Descriptions like "one brief rush" or "reaches the intended pitch" work best when you can measure a disputed clip, not just describe it. Two simple measurements settle most arguments about timing and pitch. The numbers below are made up to show the method.
Timing in milliseconds. At 80 BPM one beat lasts 60000 / 80 = 750 ms, and a sixteenth note lasts 750 / 4 = 187.5 ms. Drop the clip's audio onto a grid set to 80 BPM in any recording software and check each note against the nearest line. Say the first four downbeats land 8, 12, 35 and 60 ms late. The first two are normal for a human player. The last two get steadily later. Both are still shorter than a sixteenth note, but this is the "repeated dragging" the level 2 timing description names. One late note of 30 ms that snaps back into place is the level 3 "one brief drag".
Pitch in cents. A semitone is 100 cents, and a tuner shows cents directly. An open string within 5 cents either way counts as "instrument is tuned". A bend that stops 40 cents short of the target is an audible "intonation miss". Two of those in one passage reach the level 2 "unreliable bend pitch". A 15-cent wobble on a held note is just vibrato, not a mistake.
Measuring one disputed clip per group keeps the four levels honest. Markers see where "secure" ends in real numbers. And students get a target they can practise: "land the change within 20 ms", "finish the bend within 10 cents". "Tighten it up" gives them nothing to work on.
Four-level guitar rubric for Moodle
The full rubric is in the table below. Enter it in Moodle’s Rubrics advanced grading method. Selected levels award 20, 15, 10, or 5 points. Handle a missing submission through the assignment’s no-submission policy; it is never a demonstrated playing level.
| Criterion | 4: 20 points | 3: 15 points | 2: 10 points | 1: 5 points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | Holds the stated pulse and subdivision through starts, transitions, and releases; any recovery is musical and does not interrupt the phrase. | Pulse remains clear, with one brief rush, drag, or hesitant transition that does not derail the phrase. | Repeated rushing, dragging, or unstable subdivision changes the groove or forces a visible recovery. | Pulse cannot be maintained for the assigned material, or restarts prevent a continuous performance from being assessed. |
| Pitch | Instrument is tuned; notes, chords, and bends reach their intended pitch, with clean enough fretting to identify the harmony or melody. | One audible wrong note, chord, or intonation miss occurs, then the player corrects it without losing the line. | Wrong notes, unclear chord fretting, or unreliable bend pitch recur and obscure the assigned musical material. | Intended notes or harmony cannot be identified consistently from the recording. |
| Articulation | Attacks, note length, muting, and releases fit the style; unwanted string noise does not distract from the part. | Minor uneven attacks or string noise appear, but the line and intended accents remain clear. | Repeated noise, weak note separation, or uneven attacks blur the rhythm or melodic shape. | Articulation prevents the assessor from hearing the assigned rhythm, melody, or chord changes clearly. |
| Posture and technique | Hand position and body setup support relaxed, efficient execution; picking and fretting motions remain appropriate to the task. | A short tension or setup lapse is visible, yet it does not disrupt sound, time, or control. | Persistent tension, excess motion, or inefficient hand placement interferes with accuracy, muting, or endurance. | Visible setup or motion blocks safe, workable execution; pause, offer guidance, and arrange a supported resubmission if needed. |
| Musical continuity | Completes the assigned passage in the required recording format with a clear beginning, sustained musical intent, and controlled ending. | Completes the passage with one small lapse, hesitation, or recovery that leaves the form intact. | Stops, unannounced edits, or loss of form break the musical flow more than once. | Performance is incomplete, materially edited against the task rule, or lacks enough continuous evidence to assess. |
Include this instruction: “This criterion concerns efficient movement and sound-producing control, not appearance.” It keeps comments on motion, tension, string control, and endurance. “Your wrist angle made the pull-offs uneven after bar four” is observable; “Your posture looks wrong” is not.
A Moodle assignment students can actually complete
Build the assignment before you import the rubric. Students should see the rubric and the rules before they record. Menu labels differ between Moodle versions and themes, but keep everything in one place: the material, the recording rule, the file format, the deadline and how the rubric will be used. If a student learns about a one-take rule after recording, you have marked them on a rule they did not know.
Name the assignment after the task, so students see "Performance Check 2: Eight-Bar Guitar Study" rather than the name of a tool. The instructions are the real agreement. Give the tempo, the material, the number of repetitions, whether the click may be audible, any backing track allowed, whether edits are allowed and that both hands must stay in shot. Turn on file submissions and accept .mp4 and .mov if your server supports them, with a size limit that fits your storage and upload limits. An online text box can hold a short reflection next to the clip.
Turn on the submit button if students need a moment to check before handing in. Leave it off only if you want them to keep revising until the deadline. If feedback should lead to a resubmission, reopen attempts by hand for the students who need it, rather than for everyone. Say at the start how a first mark relates to a resubmission.
Set the maximum grade to 100, choose Rubric as the grading method and enter the five criteria and four levels exactly as published. Written feedback comments are enough for video. An annotated PDF adds nothing, and a sheet of timestamps is worth attaching only if it says more than the rubric note. Finally, let only the teacher and the student see the video unless peer review has its own consent. Keep video files under their own storage rules, because they are more sensitive than ordinary documents.
Do a quick test. Upload a phone clip from a student test account over the kind of connection students will use. Check that it plays in the browser, that the sound survives Moodle's processing and that the rubric is visible before submission. If Moodle cannot preview a common phone format, you want to know now, not on deadline night.
Keep peer marking separate from the teacher's grade until students apply the descriptions consistently. Peers can usefully answer "where did the pulse drift?" or "which note ended noisily?" Asking them to make high-stakes judgements without practice or shared examples is unfair.
Test the scoring before students submit
Before a real grade depends on it, run a dummy submission through. Pick one level per row and check that Moodle adds up the same way you do. Timing 15, Pitch 20, Articulation 10, Posture and Technique 15 and Musical Continuity 20 make 80/100, because each row is worth up to 20.
Then try the awkward cases. A clean but unfinished video can get 20 for pitch and 5 for continuity, if there is enough playing to judge pitch. A clip with unusable sound cannot get a guessed pitch score. Give the lowest level the evidence supports, or send the attempt back if your rules allow. A low mark means the skill is still developing. A broken file means you simply cannot hear the playing.
Moodle will not fix a muddled grading plan. Check that the maximum grade is 100, that markers use all five criteria and that there is no leftover draft rubric. Save or export the result, so a second teacher can reach the same 80/100 from the descriptions without asking the first what they meant.
This process is for performances. Statistics for written tests are a different topic, covered in the guide to Moodle quiz discrimination and facility indices.
Practice clips show which descriptions are vague
The best way to see whether a rubric works is to have teachers mark the same clips. Prepare two anonymised clips from the same assignment, with the students' consent. Say both are recordings of the same eight-bar guitar study at 80 BPM. The first keeps a steady pulse but shows one moment of tension in the fretting hand. The second keeps the form but has two pitch slips and a hesitant pause near the end that almost sounds like a restart.
Each teacher marks alone and writes a note before anyone talks. Nobody expects identical taste. The test is whether the descriptions make everyone notice the same things. Below is one example of such a session. It says nothing about standards in general.
On the first clip the two markers were close: 85 (T20, P15, A15, PT15, C20) against 80. They split only on posture and technique. One saw a briefly raised shoulder and a squeezed fretting hand and gave PT10. The other gave PT15. The group kept 15, because the moment was short and the sound stayed steady. They also wrote down that 10 is for tension that lasts, not for a single visible moment. The second clip opened a wider gap.
It scored 65 (T15, P10, A10, PT15, C15) against 75 (P15, C20). The argument was about two things: was the pause near the end a musical recovery or a break, and did two pitch slips count as recurring? The group set pitch at 10, because both slips hide the melody, and continuity at 15, because the player carries on without fully restarting. Then they rewrote "loss of form" in the lowest description, so the next disagreement has less room.
Repeat this when you move from strummed rhythm to single-note lead, or from a clean sound to heavy distortion. Distortion can hide weak fretting and unwanted noise. A metronome on the recording can hide whether the student really feels the subdivisions. The descriptions do not need to change for every style, but teachers must agree on what can be heard.
For peer marking, show one practice clip in class or in a private Moodle activity. Let students score only two rows, then explain how you scored it. Keep comments to timestamps and things you can hear or see. "The chord at 0:18 is cut off early" gives a student something to fix. "Needs more feel" does not.
A more musical second take
A good video rubric does not reward lifeless perfection. It points to problems a student can fix: hold the pulse through chord changes, get the bend in tune before widening the vibrato, mute a string that should be silent, relax a tense movement, or keep playing through a small slip.
The ten teachers with ten different marks are also the fairest test of the rubric. Publish it with the assignment, try it on one test clip before students record and mark two anonymised examples together. Either the teachers end up in the same band, or you see exactly which row still divides them. If any row splits teachers by a whole level, rewrite that description now, while it is cheap. Once grades are out, the same fix means remarking every video.